CubaBrief: Two Cuban Artists have spent 4 years in prison and continue jailed for living as free men and exercising their basic rights.

Freedom  /ˈfrēdəm/ noun: The power or right to act, speak, or think as one wants without hindrance or restraint. Absence of subjection to foreign domination or despotic government. The state of not being imprisoned or enslaved. Similar: liberty, liberation,independence, self-government, self-determination,  democracy, individualism, emancipation

Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara and Maykel Castillo Pérez “Osorbo”.

Freedom is a criminal offense in Cuba. The most recent penal code in Cuba enacted in 2022 explicitly punishes the right to speak, or think as one wants if it is critical of the government. The dictatorship in Cuba is a despotic government.

Thousands of Cubans were jailed during and after the nationwide nonviolent protests that demanded change in Cuba in July of 2021. Some protesters were shot by paramilitaries, and the police. Others were killed by regime agents. Hundreds were subjected to political show trials, and sentenced to prison sentences of up to 30 years.

The “trial” of these two artists concluded three years ago today on May 31, 2022 that drew more international scrutiny than the others.

Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara is a visual artist. He was last arrested, and detained on July 11, 2021 before he could join in the 11J protests mentioned above. In 2021, Time Magazine recognized Luis Manuel as one of the 100 most influential people.

Maykel Castillo Pérez “Osorbo” is a rap singer and he has been in pre-trial detention for over a year. He was taken by the political police on May 18, 2021. He is also a two-time Latin Grammy winner for the song he co-wrote and performed with other Cuban artists in 2021 called Patria y Vida.

“Castillo’s last statement to the judge during the trial was, ‘Espero que la sentencia de usted, señora jueza, sea la de su conciencia,’ which translates to: ‘I hope your sentence, madame judge, is one dictated by your conscience.,” reported NBC News.

Maykel Castillo Pérez “Osorbo”

On May 17, 2022 Luis Manuel delivered a message from prison. “In an audio recording from his prison cell at Guanajay on May 17, Otero Alcántara said: ‘I dream that no Cuban will be the enemy of any other Cuban. Today for these dreams I am ready to sacrifice the artist’s flesh, my artist’s flesh, and my freedom-loving spirit,’” reported PEN International.

Luis Manuel was sentenced to five years and Maykel Castillo to nine years in prison on a range of charges related to their participation in a peaceful demonstration and an artistic performance, and their criticism of President Miguel Díaz-Canel”, reported Amnesty International.

Reuters reported at the time that “the U.S. Embassy in Havana on [June 1, 2022] criticized the trial of two Cuban artist-dissidents as neither ‘free nor fair’ on social media, fueling a growing standoff over human rights just weeks after Washington moved to ease sanctions on the island nation.”

However, one need not rely on U.S. diplomats on the reality that trials in Cuba are neither “free nor fair.” The president of the Supreme People’s Court (TSP), Rubén Remigio Ferro, dispelled them in a video revealed by DIARIO DE CUBA entitled “How Justice Is Decided in Cuba” that demonstrates that the judiciary is subordinate to the Cuban Communist Party, the Council of State, and works with the secret police, and prosecutors office to ensure that acquittals are kept at a minimum.

This was a political trial and a mockery of justice.

People of good will are not remaining passive before this injustice. Protests have been carried out in Miami, Madrid, New York and elsewhere to demonstrate solidarity with both Luis Manuel and Maykel.

Earlier this month at the Oslo Freeedom Forum Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara was a recipient of the Václav Havel International Prize for Creative Dissent.

The Center calls on members of the international community to continue to demand the immediate release of these two imprisoned artists and human rights defenders, and the over 1,150 other Cuban political prisoners.

We are especially concerned about the plight of political prisoners Félix Navarro Rodríguez, Alexander Díaz Rodríguez, Amalio Alvarez González, Loreto Hernández García, and Virgilio Mantilla Arango.  Particular attention needs to be paid toFélix Navarro Rodríguez,  who last spoke with his wife expressing concern that he was dying, and officials continue to deny Sonia Álvarez the right to see her husband, and Alexander Díaz Rodríguez, was beaten on Wednesday, May 28, 2025 by officials at Correctional Center 25 1/2, located in Cabo de San Antonio, Cuba’s westernmost region, for refusing to engage in forced labor.

Alexander Diaz Rodríguez

We also welcome the current Administration in the United States holding repressors accountable.

Please use hashtags: #FreeMaykelOsorbo, #FreeLuisMa, #FreeFelix, and #FreeAlexander to raise awareness.

Translating Cuba, May 25, 2025

“There Will Be More Cuban Repressors Sanctioned,” Says the Head of the US Embassy in Havana

Regarding the regime’s criticism of his tours around the island, Hammer said at a press conference in Miami: “There’s nothing in the Vienna Convention that doesn’t allow that.”

14ymedio, Madrid May 23, 2025 — Mike Hammer, head of the US mission in Cuba, will continue to work as he has done in the months that he has been in office, touring the Island and approaching people. He insisted on it at a press conference held this Friday in Miami, Florida, which was broadcast live on social media.

With the affable style that characterizes him, addressing the half-dozen media in the room, he began the event by thanking “the press that does its job, in a democracy where there is freedom.” Before submitting to questions, he reiterated the line followed by the current government of Donald Trump in its policy towards the Island, headed by Secretary of State, Marco Rubio, and based on two pillars: “a return to a hard policy towards the Cuban regime” and “support for the Cuban people.”

Regarding the former, he gave as an example the sanctions announced last Wednesday on three judges and a prosecutor who intervened in the arbitrary trial of Luis Robles Elizástigui, “the young man with the banner,” stating that “there will be more. It’s a beginning, not an end,” he reiterated at question time. “This administration is determined to punish the repressors. There will be consequences for their actions, and I can’t reveal more measures that are coming but they will come, I can assure you.”

Regarding the errors that may be made in identifying repressors to punish them, or unjustly denying visas or residence to certain people, he acknowledged that there may be some but that they will continue with the tightening of the law. “What we don’t want to see is repressors walking around the streets of South Beach sipping their mojitos. That can’t be, it’s not fair for Cubans who want to come legally to the United States,” he said. “The Cuban people also tell me that it hurts to see repressors enjoying the good life here in the United States. How can it be, if we are the ’great enemy’, that every Cuban wants to come to the United States?”

The second pillar of US foreign policy towards Cuba has to do, he clearly stated, with his journey through the country. He has been, he said, in all the provinces, “from the west, in Pinar del Río, to the other end, the east, in Guantánamo.” And what he has heard from the majority, “almost all people, even some of the State machinery, is that the Revolution has failed.”

The diplomat continued: “There is no electricity, you see the blackouts, there is a shortage of fuel, there is a shortage of food, there is a shortage of medicines, and people recognize that the Cuban regime is responsible, which has nothing to do with any policy of the United States.”

“Those in the Regime who want to accuse us of one thing or another should listen to their own people,” he said, referring to the criticism he received from the Cuban government, which has described his conduct as “disrespectful”, “contrary to the rules of international law”, “unwise” and “interventionist”.

Hammer recalled his career of more than 36 years, in which, among other destinations, he was in Chile and the Congo. “As I said to the Cuban regime, I did the same thing in those countries, go out and meet people, talk to them. There is nothing in the Vienna Convention that prohibits this.”

In fact, he indicated, about Cuban diplomats on US territory, “they do it. They travel all over the United States meeting with whomever they want. Well, I’m doing the same thing; there’s nothing wrong with it.” Regarding the obligation, recently imposed by the US on these Cuban diplomats to give advance notice of their movements, he clarified that he seeks “reciprocity. It is not that they cannot go, it is that they have to notify.”

He also wondered, at various times: “What are they afraid of, if I am a simple head of mission?” He further reported that there have been threats to people not to meet with him, but that despite this, he continues to encourage them: “Keep on meeting with us, we appreciate the support.”

Asked if he does not fear that there may be an “out-of-control incident” on his tours or that they may “limit his movements,” he replied that he is not concerned about the constant surveillance he assumes is there. “Obviously there is a lot of movement, you see the Ladas everywhere. If we turn right, they turn right. I don’t like to go left – he joked – but well, if we do go left, they come with us. They are filming me constantly.”

That, he says, doesn’t matter to him: “We are saying what we are doing, it’s totally transparent.” What he is concerned about is that they have seen calls on social networks by the authorities for “trolls” and “militants” to “come and disturb” or “interrupt” their trips. It’s something, he said, “you have to keep an eye on.”

“Any state has a responsibility to protect any foreign diplomat, and I am sure that the Cuban government will comply with this.”

About the case of two Cubans with criminal records deported to South Sudan José Manuel Rodríguez Quiñones and Enrique Arias Hierr- about which the US administration has not been entirely clear, Hammer said he was aware and very familiar with the reality of South Sudan, as he was a special envoy for the Horn of Africa. “Every month there are deportation flights to Havana. We present a list, the regime reviews it, and so far they have accepted it. In cases where the regime does not want to accept them from the United States, it has to look for other options, but it is the responsibility under international law that they receive Cuban citizens.”

The journalist who inquired about the subject asked again if what he was saying is that the Government of Havana refused to receive these two compatriots, and the head of mission avoided giving details: “I prefer the answer to be given by the State Department.”

“Is Cuba a failed state?” asked another journalist, to which he replied that it is not for him to give an answer, although an opinion was allowed: “If you have hotels where there is air conditioning for foreigners and not for your people, you are not responding to the needs of your people.”

In his speech, the diplomat also called for the release of all political prisoners and defended visiting their families: “You have to give them a little support, and they appreciate it.” And he added, “It’s unusual that someone can’t go out and express themselves in peaceful protests. In all countries of the world, more or less, that can be done. That José Daniel Ferrer and Félix Navarro, who had been released, should be imprisoned again, why? Because José Daniel is feeding his community? That has nothing to do with meeting me. They know what we talk about, they have heard everything.” He also alluded to Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara and Maykel Castillo Osorbo: “Why are they afraid of some artists?”

Finally, he spoke of the entrepreneurs he has visited, especially “micro-entrepreneurs” and, above all, women, about whom he argued that they are “people who want to earn a living because there is no other way” and have “a spirit we all share here. It is worth supporting them, especially because the State does not do so.”

Translated by Regina Anavy

https://translatingcuba.com/there-will-be-more-cuban-repressors-sanctioned-says-the-head-of-the-us-embassy-in-havana/

The World, July 1, 2022

Cuban dissident artists behind hit protest song ‘Patria y Vida’ sentenced to prison

The World

Two Cuban artists who took part in composing and recording the protest hit “Patria y Vida” were sentenced to prison terms last week.

Rapper Maykel Castillo “El Osorbo” and visual artist Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara received nine-year and five-year terms, respectively, according to the island’s attorney general last Friday.

Castillo and Otero Alcántara are leaders of the San Isidro Movement, a group of Cuban artists who have used different artistic expressions to denounce political repression on the island.

“Patria y Vida,” which means “Homeland and Life” is a play on one of the most iconic slogans of the Cuban revolution, “Patria o Muerte,” meaning “homeland or death.” It was a phrase used by revolutionary Che Guevara, and one that former Cuban President Fidel Castro often used to end his speeches.

And the new song quickly became the anthem for last July’s historic demonstrations that demanded an end to economic misery and political repression in Cuba.

Their song was released early last year by a group of Cuban artists both living in Cuba and in exile. Castillo and Romero Alcántara, along with rapper Eliécer Marquez “El Funky” were the only ones who recorded their portions of the music video in Cuba itself.

“It was difficult [to record the video from Cuba] because we were hiding the whole time. We knew if we took a wrong step, there was no video,” said Castillo in an interview with Noticias CubaNet, a Cuban news outlet, right before the video was released, in February.

Months later, thousands of people absorbed its message and were marching to the “Patria y Vida” slogan across the country.

In Cuba, criticizing the government is officially against the law. Nearly 1,500 people were arrested in relation to the protests, and half of them remain in jail, according to 11J, an organization that tracks detentions in Cuba.

The Cuban government accused the San Isidro Movement of “catalyzing the protests” and called it a cultural counterrevolution sponsored by the United States’ government.

Castillo was detained in May 2021 for participating in a protest a month earlier. He remained incarcerated until last week when he was found guilty of “contempt, public disorder, and defamation of institutions and organizations, heroes and martyrs,” according to the Cuban attorney general office.

Alcántara Otero was detained on July 11 — the very day that the protests erupted — after he posted on social media his intentions to join the demonstrations. The court argued his “express intention, sustained over time, of offending the national flag, through the publication of photos on social media where it is used in denigrating acts, accompanied by notoriously offensive and disrespectful expressions, underestimating nationalistic feelings and pride the Cuban people profess to our national flag,” the attorney general office said in the statement.

Castillo has also been prosecuted for a performance in 2019 in which he wore the Cuban flag draped over his shoulders for 30 days straight, a response to a Cuban law limiting the ways that the national flag can be displayed. In the video clip of “Patria y Vida,” Castillo appears with the Cuban flag wrapped around his back.

Meanwhile, rapper Eliécer Márquez was able to leave Cuba and spoke from Miami, where he now lives and continues his activism.

“Maykel [Castillo] and Luis [Otero Alcántara] are in prison because they have a big reach,” Márquez said. “The government is afraid of them.”

Márquez expressed sadness and frustration “because no-one can do anything for them.”

Castillo and Otero Alcántara are both being held at a high-security prison and they are not in good health, Márquez said.

Supporters of the revolution also said the song itself was sponsored by the United States government. In 2014, an investigation from The Associated Press found a US agency secretly infiltrated Cuba’s underground hip-hop movement, recruiting unwitting rappers to spark a youth movement against the government.

But Márquez denied these accusations.

“This was an independent project launched by internationally renowned musicians, we don’t need that kind of support,” he said.

“The regime has given Cubans three options if they don’t want to go along with the dictatorship: prison, death and exile,” said John Suarez, executive director of Center for a Free Cuba in Washington, DC.

He said the Cuban regime was terrified by the song after it became a hit, so it banned it on the island.

“They didn’t want these messages of liberation and freedom spreading into the population,” he added.

“Patria y Vida” now has more than 11.3 million views on YouTube and won two Latin Grammy awards last November.

Susan Thomas, a musicologist who studies Cuban music and its relation to culture and politics, said this song is a rare instance when Cuban artists directly attack the regime.

“Cuba has a long and rich history of music inspired by politics, but for the most part, critical voices have been using allusion, metaphors and allegory as the common ways of getting into the critique,” Thomas said.

The lyrics in “Patria y Vida” accuse the Cuban regime of ruining the quality of life on the island.

“No more lies, our people are asking for freedom/No more doctrines/We don’t say homeland or death anymore, but homeland and life/We are not afraid anymore. … It’s time to build what we dream of, what they destroyed with their hands.”

According to Thomas, the song features an interesting combination of factors that helped it become a hit.

“It’s very catchy, it’s openly critical, it’s mass-mediated and it pairs artists who have had international careers. It is a dangerous combination if you don’t want certain messages spreading into the population.”

Groups, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Foundation and Freedom House have denounced the lack of a fair trial for Castillo and Otero Alcántara, and are calling for their immediate release.

https://theworld.org/stories/2022/07/01/cuban-court-sentences-two-prominent-artists-prison-terms

 

Translating Cuba, May 31, 2022

In Havana, It is Not Two Men Who Are Judged, But a Symbol

Otero Alcántara and Maykel Castillo in Havana, when they were still free. (Anamely Ramos)

14ymedio, Yoani Sánchez, Generation Y, 31 May 2022 — The last Monday of May dawned cloudy and humid in Havana. However, it was not the possibility of a shower or the difficulties of getting around in a city paralyzed by the fuel crisis that were the main features of the day. In the Court of Marianao, a neighborhood in the western part of the Cuban capital, a trial is taking place that thousands of eyes are watching. The artist Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara and the rapper Maykel Castillo Osorbo are the accused.

Although in recent months oral hearings against those who participated in the popular demonstrations of last July, or to sentence citizens who show their disagreement on social networks have become common, this week’s process marks a climax of repression in the country. Otero Alcántara is being tried, among other crimes, for placing the Cuban flag on his body for days, in an artistic action that has annoyed a ruling party that hijacked the national emblems for its particular ideological and partisan crusade.

For his part, Osorbo is blamed for having insulted the figure of the ruler Miguel Díaz-Canel and for holding Prime Minister Manuel Marrero responsible for the lack of supplies in hospitals. Both accusations, with a prosecutor’s request for seven and ten years respectively, would hardly carry a small fine in democratic nations or, simply, would not constitute a crime under a rule of law. But the two artists have been in jail for long months and are only now being brought before a court, whose ruling is governed more by the whims of a group in power than by the rigors of justice.

To avoid showing solidarity with the defendants, the surroundings of the Court woke up under a strong police and security services operation, the telephone lines and Internet access of innumerable activists and independent journalists were cut, and an intense campaign of demonization was deployed on social networks to try to counter any show of support for Otero Alcántara and Osorbo. But the effect of this offensive seems to be just the opposite of what the regime is seeking: people who were not aware of the trial have found out after inquiring about the many uniformed men they have seen in that part of the city, and the insistence on defining them as “criminals” in the official media has aroused more sympathy than rejection.

In the hands of Castroism — like a hot potato that burns if held between the fingers and ridicules if it is dropped — are the lives of two young people who represent the failure of a system. Coming from a humble neighborhood, both were supposed to blindly embrace the political model established in the country more than six decades ago because, according to official propaganda, they are part of the sectors most favored by the Revolution. But instead of that, Otero Alcántara and Osorbo have denounced the lies and arbitrariness of the leaders in olive green, the poverty of their neighborhood of San Isidro and police impunity.

By arresting and judging them, the Cuban system itself is showing that it only accepts total obedience from citizens, never criticism or dissidence in any of its forms. It has turned them into a banner of the fragility of a citizenry that has been cut off from all peaceful paths to change the status quo.

In the next few days the sentence against the two artists will be known. It is very likely that they are sentences designed to send an exemplary message to the rest of the population. But the Cuban regime has already lost this battle, it can lock up their bodies for years but it will not be able to put behind bars the symbol they have become.

________________________

Editorial Note: This text was originally published in Deutsche Welle in Spanish.

https://translatingcuba.com/in-havana-it-is-not-two-men-who-are-judged-but-a-symbol/

Reuters, June 1, 2022

U.S. embassy says trial of Cuban artist-activists ‘neither free nor fair’

Jun 1, 2022 | 2:51 PM

HAVANA (Reuters) – The U.S. Embassy in Havana on Wednesday criticized the trial of two Cuban artist-dissidents as neither “free nor fair” on social media, fueling a growing standoff over human rights just weeks after Washington moved to ease sanctions on the island nation.

Activists Luis Manuel Otero Alcantara and Maykel Castillo were awaiting announcement a verdict after standing trial in Havana on Monday and Tuesday. They face seven and 10 years in jail, respectively, for alleged crimes ranging from contempt to assault.

The U.S. Embassy said on Twitter that the trial violated the human rights of Otero Alcantara and Castillo and called for their immediate release.

“To no one’s surprise, the trial was neither free nor fair. The regime used trumped up charges. They are being persecuted for their art and opinions,” the U.S. Embassy said.

Neither a group of European diplomats nor foreign journalists were authorized to attend this week’s trial. Reuters submitted a request to the Cuban government to enter the courthouse but did not receive a response.

A Cuban state-run radio program on Tuesday accused the U.S. Embassy of “politicizing” a normal judicial process, saying the alleged crimes at issue in the trial were clearly described in Cuba’s penal code.

“No profession exonerates anyone from being brought to trial for a crime. If you are an artist and you commit a crime, you must respond to the law,” the radio report said.

Otero Alcantara and Castillo are members of a Havana-based artists collective that spearheaded an unusual wave of small protests before most left Cuba, alleging repression. Both men also appeared in the music video for the Latin Grammy-winning song Patria y Vida, the unofficial anthem of widespread anti-government protests on the island last July 11.

Cuban state media have called Castillo and Otero Alcantara’s San Isidro Movement part of a U.S.-directed “soft coup” attempt, charges they deny.

The U.S. Embassy has continued to blast Cuba’s handling of trials – and has moved to limit Cuba’s participation in the upcoming regional Summit of the Americas – even as the administration of President Joe Biden moved to ease sanctions on the island in May.

(Reporting by Dave Sherwood and Nelson Acosta; Editing by Bill Berkrot)

https://wtvbam.com/2022/06/01/u-s-embassy-says-trial-of-cuban-artist-activists-neither-free-nor-fair/

NBC News, May 31, 2022

In Cuba, trial against high profile anti-government activists concludes

Artist Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara and rapper Maykel Castillo now await sentencing, as international groups call for their release.

May 31, 2022, 5:51 PM EDT

By Carmen Sesin

The trial of artist Luis Manuel Otero Alcántara and rapper Maykel Castillo, two of the most prominent anti-government activists in Cuba, concluded Tuesday.

A verdict is expected in the next two weeks, though it can take longer, according to Cuban activist Anamely Ramos.

Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International have been calling for their release.

Trials in Cuba are closed to the media and only relatives are allowed in the courtroom.

Otero Alcántara is facing seven years in prison on charges of defaming the Cuban flag, contempt and public disorder. Castillo is charged with contempt, resisting arrest, assault and defamation of national institutions. He faces up to 10 years in jail, according to Ramos.

Cuban activists have insisted both men are innocent of the charges.

Otero Alcántara was detained on July 11, 2021, the day the island exploded in protests against the Communist government. Castillo was detained in May 2021.

The joint trial has garnered worldwide attention. Castillo was one of the composers of the Latin Grammy award-winning song “Patria y Vida” (“Homeland and Life”), which became an anthem during the July protests. Images of Otero Alcántara appear in the music video as well. Time magazine named Otero Alcántara one of the 100 most influential people of 2021.

Both men were involved with the San Isidro Movement, a collective of artists and activists who are critical of the government’s censorship. It was named after the Havana neighborhood where Otero Alcántara resides.

Many of the members of the San Isidro Movement are no longer in Cuba; Ramos is one of them. The activist, who is in contact with relatives who attended the trial, told NBC News from New York that Castillo’s last statement to the judge during the trial was, “Espero que la sentencia de usted, señora jueza, sea la de su conciencia,” which translates to: “I hope your sentence, madame judge, is one dictated by your conscience.”

Castillo had to find a new attorney just three days before the trial began, Ramos said, because the lawyer who had worked on his defense for months was removed. Ramos called the trial a “circus.”

Ramos is stranded in the U.S. after she was prevented in February from boarding a flight to Havana from Miami; she said she has been barred from re-entering her country.

Cuba’s government has not commented publicly on the cases of Otero Alcántara and Castillo. State-run media has previously said both men receive funds from the U.S. government and has called the San Isidro Movement a “farce.”

Follow NBC News Latino on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/latino/cuba-trial-high-profile-anti-government-activists-concludes-rcna31204

Diario de Cuba, May 31, 2022

Laws

‘Justice the Cuban Way’: Collusion between the Supreme Court, the Prosecutor’s Office and the MININT

The President of the Supreme People’s Court admits that, according to the universal theory of criminal law, Cuban judges’ impartiality is compromised.

Lucía Alfonso Mirabal

La Habana 31 Mayo 2022

If there were any doubts as to the subordination to the regime of those charged with administering justice in Cuba (and therefore, in theory, being impartial) the president of the Supreme People’s Court (TSP), Rubén Remigio Ferro, dispelled them in a video revealed by DIARIO DE CUBA entitled “How Justice Is Decided in Cuba.”

The material is of a meeting chaired by the TSP’s president, with Attorney General Yamila Peña Ojeda and TSP Vice-President Marisela Sosa Ravelo in attendance. Also present are the president of the TSP’s Criminal Court, that of the State Security Crimes Court, and all the heads, at the national and provincial levels, of the Ministry of the Interior’s (MININT) General Directorate of Criminal Investigation and Operations.

Although it is a November 2018 video, the trials of the 11J protesters, and the magistrate’s words when referring to the “current and prospective context,” show that nothing had changed in 2021, two years after the entry into force of the Constitution approved in 2019, or in 2022, when the trials and sentences continue against Cubans who dared in July 2021 to demand changes and the end of Communism on the island.

Remigio Ferro makes it clear that judges in Cuba are “judges of the Revolution and the Party.” The TSP president himself recognizes that a meeting like the one we see in the video would be “unthinkable” in another country.

In democratic countries, where there is a separation of powers, and where defendants have the right to a fair trial, where judges have the duty to recuse themselves if for any reason they have a conflict of interest compromising their impartiality in a certain judicial process, there are no meetings in which the president of a court arranges with the prosecutor, behind the defense lawyers’ backs, how he should proceed.

The President of the TSP forgot about Article 57 of the Constitution, which states that “the function of dispensing justice emanates from the people and is exercised on their behalf by the People’s Supreme Court and the other courts established by law.”

The people of Cuba, however, are not the Communist Party of Cuba (CCP). In fact, president Miguel Díaz-Canel himself recently acknowledged that of the little more than 10 million people who live on the island, only a little more than 1 million (including members of the UJC, the Young Communists Union, even though not all of them wish to join the ranks of the Party) belong to the PCC.

Therefore, judges in Cuba represent just only 10% of the population – the 10% that belongs to the Party. And, as the disproportionate prosecutorial demands and sentences of the 11J protesters have shown, those who challenge the Party and the Revolution, to which the judges bear allegiance, do not receive justice. Remigio Ferro himself contradicted the regime’s position when, after the protests, he stated that demonstrating, or exercising one’s freedom of opinion, of the press, of belief, and even of political and ideological affiliation, does not constitute a crime. In his own words, protesting was “an individual’s constitutional right.”

But constitutional rights in Cuba are curtailed, as evidenced by the new Penal Code, which criminalizes the “excessive exercise of constitutional rights.” And the parameters governing the enjoyment of these rights are not determined by the freedom or rights of other citizens, but rather by the interests of the Party to which, Rubén Remigio Ferro acknowledges, judges in Cuba are beholden.

It should also be kept in mind that this video, recorded with the knowledge of those present, to be circulated only between the presidents and vice-presidents of the Cuban provincial courts, dates from to a time when the approval of the Constitution, to replace that of 1976, was being promoted

The Constitution approved in 2019, on paper, and according to the Cuban regime and the TSP president himself, does more to guarantee individuals rights than the previous one. For Remigio Ferro, however, these guarantees are a problem, as is the fact that the defendants in a trial can count on defense lawyers, from the beginning.

The magistrate refers to defense lawyers as “dogs in the tobacco” (that is, a nuisance), a position at odds with the impartiality that judges are supposed to embrace, especially him, as president of the TSP and its Governing Council.

It is somewhat understandable for the police and State Security officers to consider the presence of defense lawyers from the beginning of the justice process to be irksome, but it is outrageous that this is the view of those charged with ensuring that justice, absolute equality between the parties, and respect for due process, prevail.

The collusion between the president of the TSP, the Prosecutor’s Office and the MININT against lawyers and defendants (note that any lawyers from the state’s Organization of Collective Law Firms were conspicuously missing from the meeting) is completely laid bare when Remigio Ferro addressed the issue of returning case files to the prosecution, which usually rankles public prosecutors and investigators.

By returning the files, however, the courts send “a signal,” as explained by the TSP president, for the prosecution to redress deficiencies and weaknesses in the evidence that could end up forcing the judge to acquit the accused.

Remigio Ferro explains that if there are fewer returns there will be more acquittals (which in Cuba only constitute between 6% and 8% of the cases processed, which he considers good numbers).

His words were “we could remove the stress entailed by the returns (…) but you’d  see the number of acquittals rise.”

The president of the TSP admits that, according to the theory of criminal law, it is not proper for the court to return files, as this means that it is compromising its impartiality, and that this is a “universal theory taught at universities.” But these universal theories do not count in Cuba, where justice is imparted “the Cuban way,” the magistrate acknowledged.

Although the meeting addressed common crimes and made no reference to prosecutions against citizens for opposing the regime (though this is never recognized in the country, where dissidents and activists are, formally, imprisoned for alleged common crimes) it is easy to deduce what those who openly demonstrate against the Government and the PCC can expect from the justice system.

The President of the TSP’s remarks at this meeting in 2018 bear out the statements given by former prosecutor Raucel Ocaña Parada, from Palma Soriano (Santiago de Cuba) to the Cuban Observatory of Human Rights (OCDH) in early May 2022.

Ocaña Parada, now in exile, protested that the trials against 11J demonstrators were being manipulated by “bodies and institutions subject to the interests of the State, the Government and the Communist Party of Cuba” and that it was “in the interest of the Government, the State and the Party” that they be sanctioned with the greatest possible severity, “without any kind of benevolence.”

https://diariodecuba.com/cuba/1654010483_39882.html